top of page

Best Super Bowl Exotic Bets

Updated: 6 days ago

  • National Anthem Length: Over/Under 2 minutes for Jon Batiste's performance.
  • Coin Toss: Heads or tails? A classic 50/50 bet.
  • First Timeout Caller: Eagles or Chiefs - who manages the clock first?
  • First Coaches Challenge: Which coach will throw the first flag?
  • Overtime: Will the game go into overtime? Odds are steep but intriguing.
  • Opening Kickoff Touchback: Will the first kick result in a touchback?
  • Gatorade Color: Bet on the color of the winning team's celebratory shower.
  • Octopus Bet: Will a player score a touchdown and a two-point conversion?

Platforms like BettorEdge enhance the experience with no-vig, peer-to-peer betting for better odds. Dive into the details, trends, and strategies for these prop bets to make your Super Bowl LIX viewing even more thrilling.


Best Super Bowl Exotic Prop Bets: Coin Toss & Gatorade Color


1. National Anthem Length (Over/Under 2 minutes - Jon Batiste)

One of the most talked-about Super Bowl LIX prop bets is the length of the national anthem, performed this year by Grammy winner Jon Batiste. BettorEdge community has set the over/under line at 2 minutes.

Looking at past data can help guide your bet. Historically, Super Bowl anthems usually last between 1 minute 45 seconds and 2 minutes 15 seconds. The average length has crept up recently, with the last ten performances averaging 2 minutes and 2 seconds. However, seven of those ten came in under the 2-minute mark [4].

There’s a lot of variation when it comes to anthem performances. Neil Diamond's 1:22 rendition is among the shortest, while Alicia Keys stretched hers to 2:35. Jon Batiste, known for his jazz roots, hasn't performed the anthem at a Super Bowl yet, but his style suggests he might lean toward a more elaborate and extended version.

Here’s what to consider before placing your bet:

  • Conditions: The acoustics of the Caesars Superdome and the event's gravity could influence the performance.
  • Trends: Recent anthems have leaned slightly longer.
  • Batiste’s Style: His jazz background hints at possible improvisation and embellishments.
"This unpredictable pre-game moment sets the tone for the Super Bowl."

For those looking to maximize value, BettorEdge’s no-vig marketplace ensures competitive odds, no matter which side you pick.

With the anthem setting the mood, it’s time to dive into another iconic moment - the coin toss.


2. Coin Toss (Heads or Tails)

The Super Bowl coin toss is one of the simplest bets in sports - a straightforward 50/50 chance. While many sportsbooks set odds at -105 for heads or tails, BettorEdge users often get true +100 odds, giving bettors the best possible value.

Over the years, the results have been almost evenly split, with tails slightly ahead recently. However, each flip is completely random, and prior outcomes have no impact on future results. It's a pure game of chance.

What makes the coin toss so appealing? Its simplicity and quick outcome. You’ll know the result before the game even begins, making it a great way to kick off your Super Bowl betting experience.

"The coin toss is one of several exotic betting markets available for the Super Bowl, offering a variety of betting options beyond traditional game outcomes" [4].

With BettorEdge’s no-vig marketplace, you get unmatched value for this classic Super Bowl tradition. Once the coin toss settles, attention shifts to another intriguing question: which team will call the first timeout? That decision can set the tone for the game’s opening moments.


3. First Timeout Caller (Eagles or Chiefs)

Placing a bet on which team will call the first timeout can add an extra layer of excitement to Super Bowl 59. This wager depends heavily on each team's approach to clock management and decision-making under pressure.

The Philadelphia Eagles, led by Nick Sirianni, tend to be cautious with their timeouts, averaging just 1.4 unnecessary timeouts per game [1]. On the other hand, Andy Reid of the Kansas City Chiefs has faced criticism for some of his timeout decisions in critical moments. One NFL commentator once said:

"That is brutal coaching by Andy Reid for me. I don't understand calling a timeout. Just challenge the spot." [2]

Several factors can influence which team calls the first timeout:

  • Away teams often face communication issues in noisy stadiums, leading to more timeouts [3].
  • Only head coaches are allowed to call timeouts from the sideline [4].
  • Early momentum shifts can force teams to pause and adjust their game plan.

For bettors, platforms like BettorEdge offer better odds without added fees, giving you more value for bets on moments like this. While past trends can guide predictions, the Super Bowl's high-stakes environment makes this type of bet especially unpredictable.

As timeout strategies take center stage, the next big question is which team will make the first coaches challenge.


4. First Coaches Challenge

Betting on which coach will throw the first challenge flag adds an extra layer of strategy and excitement to the Super Bowl. With BettorEdge's no-vig marketplace, bettors can enjoy competitive odds on this intriguing wager.

Several elements play a role in determining the likelihood of an early challenge:

Game Momentum: Teams that find themselves struggling early may challenge calls to try and regain control. In the Super Bowl, where every play is critical, this can be a game-changing move.

Coaching Style: Coaches known for bold decision-making are often quicker to throw the challenge flag. Their willingness to take risks can be amplified in the intense environment of the Super Bowl.

This bet keeps fans on edge right from kickoff, as every close call could trigger a challenge. Coaches with strong challenge success rates are especially worth watching, as they tend to act with confidence.

Key factors to consider:

  • Situations like contested catches or ball placement early in the game
  • Each coach's history of challenges in playoff games
  • How the high-stakes nature of the Super Bowl influences decisions

BettorEdge's peer-to-peer platform lets bettors track these wagers live while offering some of the best odds available. As coaching decisions come under the spotlight, let’s turn to another thrilling possibility: will the game head into overtime?


5. Game Going to Overtime

Betting on whether the Super Bowl will go into overtime can be a high-risk, high-reward opportunity. On BettorEdge, the odds are set at +2400 for "Yes" and -2400 for "No", making it an intriguing option for those willing to take a chance. Historically, Super Bowl overtime is incredibly rare - it has only happened twice in 58 years: Super Bowl LI in 2017 and Super Bowl LVIII in 2024.

What sets BettorEdge apart is its peer-to-peer betting model, which removes the house edge. This means you get true market value for your wagers, making it especially appealing for bets like this one that carry significant risk.


Factors Worth Considering:

  • Close Games Are Common: In 2023, 70% of NFL games were decided by one score or less in the fourth quarter.
  • Overtime Coin Toss Advantage: Teams winning the overtime coin toss in playoff games since 2010 have a 10-2 record.
  • New Overtime Rules: Both teams are now guaranteed at least one possession, which could impact how bettors approach this prop.

When deciding on this bet, think about how the teams perform under pressure, their record in tight games, and their ability to score late in the game. While the odds may seem steep, recent trends suggest that overtime is not entirely out of the question in a championship setting.

BettorEdge's no-vig system gives you the best possible odds for this bet. Its transparent, peer-to-peer structure ensures you're getting maximum value, whether you're betting for or against overtime.

And if the suspense of overtime isn't enough, you might also want to check out another popular prop bet: whether the opening kickoff will result in a touchback.


6. Opening Kickoff Touchback

The opening kickoff touchback bet for Super Bowl 59 has odds on BettorEdge set at Yes (-270) and No (+270). Historically, touchbacks on the opening kickoff have been rare, happening in just four of the last 32 Super Bowls. This is largely due to the unique game ball used, which affects kicking distance.

Interestingly, the 2023-24 season saw a drop in league-wide touchback rates, falling to 63.5% from 73.0% the previous year. The Kansas City Chiefs, however, posted an impressive 83.3% touchback rate during the regular season, ranking in the NFL's top 10. But Super Bowl conditions often differ from regular-season patterns.

Several factors could play a role in this bet:

  • Indoor conditions at the Caesars Superdome generally support longer kicks
  • New 2024 NFL kickoff rules have led to more touchbacks overall
  • The Super Bowl game ball is known to affect kicking distance

BettorEdge's peer-to-peer marketplace ensures competitive odds for this prop bet. With the opening kickoff setting the stage for the game, it’s time to look at another fun tradition - the Gatorade shower.


7. Gatorade Color of Winning Team

The Gatorade shower is a classic Super Bowl tradition, and betting on the color adds an extra layer of excitement. Looking at past Super Bowls, blue and red have been the top choices, with blue taking the edge in recent years.

If you're thinking about placing a bet, BettorEdge's no-vig model ensures competitive odds for this quirky prop. While it might seem like a random guess, a few factors could help you make a more informed choice:

  • Teams often pick Gatorade colors that match their uniforms - like the Chiefs' red.
  • Since Super Bowl 59 is indoors at the Caesars Superdome, weather won’t play a role.
  • Historical team habits can offer clues about their preferences.

In previous Super Bowls, teams like the Eagles (blue) and Patriots (red) have stuck to Gatorade colors that reflect their branding. This pattern might be worth considering as you make your prediction.

BettorEdge makes betting on traditions like the Gatorade shower even more fun with its no-vig marketplace and competitive odds. And if you're feeling adventurous, you can always explore other unique bets, like wagering on an 'Octopus' event.


8. Occurrence of an Octopus

An 'Octopus' happens when a player scores a touchdown and follows it up with a two-point conversion. It's a rare feat in football and has gained attention as a unique Super Bowl prop bet. Jalen Hurts made history during Super Bowl LVII by recording the first-ever Octopus in the big game. Since 1994, there have only been 188 instances of this happening. To put it into perspective, the 2023-24 regular season saw just 11 Octopuses.

For Super Bowl 59, BettorEdge offers no-vig odds on this unusual prop bet, making it an enticing option for bettors. Here are some factors to consider when assessing the chances of an Octopus:

  • Historical Frequency: Octopuses occur in only 2.25% of NFL games, underscoring their rarity.
  • Team Tendencies: Neither the Chiefs nor the 49ers lean heavily on two-point conversion attempts. This season, the Chiefs tried just one, while the 49ers didn’t attempt any.
  • Key Players: Both Patrick Mahomes and Christian McCaffrey have achieved one Octopus in their careers, making them players to watch.

Given how rare this bet is, the odds reflect its longshot nature. Traditional sportsbooks typically offer odds around +1400 for "Yes" and -2500 for "No." However, BettorEdge's no-vig marketplace provides better value for bets like the Octopus, making it a standout option for Super Bowl 59. If you're looking for a high-reward, unconventional bet, this is one to consider.


Conclusion

Super Bowl 59 brings plenty of exciting betting options, from pre-game props to in-game events. BettorEdge's no-vig marketplace stands out by offering better returns and a unique way to wager, thanks to its active community of bettors sharing insights.

Here’s what makes BettorEdge a standout choice:

  • No vig: You get true odds without extra charges.
  • Community-driven insights: Tap into a network of bettors sharing strategies.
  • Customizable betting options: Set your own odds or sell bets back to others.

Fun bets like the Octopus or the Gatorade shower add extra excitement but require a thoughtful approach. Look at team habits, historical trends, and current conditions to guide your picks. BettorEdge makes this easier by hosting all betting markets in one place, supported by a community sharing tips and strategies.

When planning your Super Bowl 59 bets, stick to props that match your expertise and interests. Always bet responsibly and use the data and insights available to make informed choices. With BettorEdge’s user-friendly platform and its community-driven approach, you’re set to enjoy all the action and make smarter bets for the big game.


FAQs

Here are some answers to common questions about Super Bowl 59 exotic bets to help you get a better understanding:


What are the odds on the coin toss in the Super Bowl?

For Super Bowl 59, BettorEdge provides true +100 odds for both heads and tails, reflecting the 50-50 chance of the outcome. This is a better deal compared to traditional sportsbooks, which usually offer lower odds.


How does the national anthem length bet work?

The Over/Under for Jon Batiste's national anthem is set at 2 minutes. To make an informed bet, think about his singing style and how long his past performances have been.


What are the odds for the game going to overtime?

The odds strongly favor the game ending in regulation time: No (-2400) vs. Yes (+2400). Since overtime is rare in Super Bowl history, this bet is considered one of the more unusual options.


What is the most likely Gatorade color for the winning team?

Orange has been the most frequent choice in the past, but blue has taken the spotlight in the last two Super Bowls. Team preferences and past trends might help in making your pick.


How does the opening kickoff touchback bet work?

The odds for the opening kickoff being a touchback are Yes (-270) and No (+270). Factors like the kicker's strength, weather, and the return team's approach can influence this outcome. The bet is decided as soon as the first kickoff happens.


What makes BettorEdge different for Super Bowl betting?

BettorEdge stands out by offering no-vig bets, meaning there are no commission fees. You get true odds, unlike traditional sportsbooks.


What is an "Octopus" bet?

An Octopus bet happens when a player scores a touchdown and then also completes the two-point conversion. It’s a rare event, occurring in just 2.25% of NFL games.

These FAQs cover some of the more interesting betting options for Super Bowl 59, with BettorEdge's no-vig platform providing a unique way to place your bets.


Related Blog Posts

bottom of page